Thursday, December 8, 2011

A Clarification? An Apology? A Clari-logy? An Apol-ification?

I expected the response I got yesterday.

I did.

And thus, I am still making my way through the e-mails and responding to each and everyone of you with respect, whether you agreed with me or not. (If you didn't attach an e-mail address to your profile, but would like a response, please note below. Many of you would be surprised that I have rather kind things to say to you. I even agree with some of you that weren't too kind to me.)

That being said, I do realize that my "blog persona" is not really anything like my real-life self.

But I'm not so sure all of you realize that.

The fact of the matter is, in person, I'm straight-up boring. I'm not at all confrontational. I'm really happy being me, with my family, by myself.

But I am a trained journalist. I do, and always have, written with authority. It's something ingrained in me; I can't get rid of it.

I'm not a quiet person, but on paper (or the Internet?), I'm even louder.

In my real life, though, I really don't take myself that seriously. At all.

In fact, if you met me in real life, you'd probably not even label me such an extremist, attachment parent.

After all, I love to wear my baby, but I also adore my stroller. Ella and I jog in it every day, and, well, sometimes? I just do not want to deal with the hassle of strapping her into the Ergo carrier.

And, yes, we co-sleep. But my baby also sleeps in her crib for at least the first half of the night, most nights. I have stuff to do around my house, and sometimes, my husband and I like to have a few moments alone without a baby. So into the crib she goes.

And, yeah, I don't let my baby cry it out. But there has been a day or two where I have literally yelled in my infants face, "Please SHUT UP ALREADY!" then put her in her bed and closed the door so I could have a few moments to compose myself. Can't say I'm proud of it, but I birthed a stubborn child, and sometimes, she gets the best of me.

The fact of the matter is, sometimes, I just need a moment without Ella. I plan my week around when I can go to the grocery store. Without her.

And, yeah, I love breast-feeding. But sometimes, I'd give my right arm so that she'd just take a darn bottle of pumped milk already. So I could leave her for more than 90 minutes without guilt. So maybe someone other than me could put her to bed one night in this lifetime.

I hold Ella a lot, but she also spends time in her exer-saucer. She's with me all day, but some part of those days are spent in her bouncy seat.

I don't vaccinate my child, but man alive, have I had a moment or two where I've stared at her and thought, "Dear God, is she getting whooping cough? Have I gone and killed my baby?"

I am not perfect. Not in a long shot.

I've yelled at my husband because he can leave her to go to work. And I can't.

I've cried tears of frustration because I just want a darn latte, but I can't have dairy or caffeine, thanks to the fact that I've, quite honestly, over-researched what should and shouldn't be consumed while breast-feeding. (Ignorance can be such bliss.)

And yesterday? Well, yesterday I literally walked around with my yoga pants on backwards. For six straight hours.

The best part was, the last hour? I had already realized it, and I was just too lazy to go whip them around. I even thought, "Oh, heck, who cares? Ella came out of me. It's not like she cares that the butt of my pants is now giving me one very saggy crotch shot."

I poke fun at myself a lot, too.

I had a dear friend - who full on told me she loved her epidural-births and wouldn't have it any other way (to which I responded, "Good for you!" for the record) - who asked me for a teething solution for her son that's Ella's age.

My response?

"Well, I can get you an amber teething necklace to borrow, but you know me and my crazy hippie crap. Even I don't know if it actually works sometimes."

We laughed while she gave her son a bottle of milk while I nursed my daughter. We get along perfectly fine and often don't discuss our differences. But when we do, it's with the utmost respect for each other.
***
I'm also a walking oxymoron. At a cookie swap next week, I'm making a healthy chocolate chip cookie.

And pound cake. With three sticks of butter.

It's horrible for you. And it's amazing all in the same bite.

Heck, I think I'm wrong for eating it. But sometimes, well, a girl's just wrong. I'm not scared of that.

My own mother had a C-section, three of them, actually. That's how I was born. And I have an awesome mother. She and I just made different choices. Her right was not my right, and her wrong was not my wrong, and, well, that's OK. That, for me, doesn't make a lick of difference in how good of a parent my own mother was.

Why should it? Our status as good mothers is not contingent on conclusions we reach or choices we make, different or alike.

Love does.
***
The fact of the matter is, I don't feel threatened when people think I'm wrong.

I had a woman tell me a few weeks back, upon learning that my child was un-vaccinated at a mutual friend's play-date, to "keep your filthy little germ-breeder" away from her.

I was kind of shocked and appalled at her tone. But I didn't really take offense that she thought I was out-and-out wrong not to vaccinate Ella, as she proceeded to expound on later.

Honestly, I've always felt that I'm secure enough in my decisions that people's disagreements with me don't bother me.

In fact, as many of you stated yesterday, it's only when I doubt myself that I often find myself wounded by people I believe are judging me.

As I get older, that happens less and less.

I also find myself growing more and more confident in my choices. And more and more imperfect, as a whole. I am woefully human, after all.

I don't know. Maybe I'm not sensitive enough. Maybe I'm lacking an empathy gene or something.

I know I hurt people's feelings yesterday, and whether or not you believe me, that was never my intention.

Did I want to make a point? Sure.

But the fact of the matter is, I am too darn busy with my own life to notice whether or not someone chooses to formula-feed their child. In fact, most of the time, if I actually notice someone with formula in hand, I assume it's because they have a need for it; contrary to popular belief, I don't judge based on snap assumptions.

And, when weighing a lot of individual situations, I can see why something I think is wrong in some instances - let's just say formula, again, for continuities sake - can be the right choice in others. It's for reasons like this that I don't concern myself with others' choices on a day-to-day basis, unless they expressly ask for my opinion.

For instance, I have never once left a negative comment on any blog I read, even when they disagree with me, name-call my methods and parents like me, or use a tone I find offensive. (And I have seen many of those posts. And yeah, they weren't so nice. But I truly don't feel the urge to call the writer out on that, either.)

If I really don't like the material, I will stop reading. Some of you did that here yesterday, and that is totally your right. I don't have a problem with that.

But very often, I simply think that my issue with what's written and my opinion of the author's tone is simply that - my opinion. It's coming from my perspective. That isn't the writer's problem that I took it that way, and often enough, I will continue to read. Unless you list my name off word for word, I don't take anything personally.

In other words, yes, I have convictions, but unless you broach those convictions with me, I don't bring it up.

Though the woman who saw me nursing my baby the other day sure did when she immediately quipped, "Isn't she a little old for that?"

But other than being shocked, I didn't really reply.

On my blog, I write about what's important to me, but in the real world, unless asked, I don't just start spouting off about it.

In fact, I'm much more likely to comment on your adorable baby's outfit - What can I say? I'm a sucker for a romper! - than ask what if you had a vaginal delivery.

Because honestly, who just out-and-out asks a woman, "So, uh, did that baby of yours come out of your lady bits?"
***
I"m really not that intense in person.

I'm just a mom trying to survive.

I'm just a mom who honest-to-goodness never wants to hurt anybody.

I don't think every decision I make has a right or wrong answer. There are multiple ways to discipline children, for instance. I don't think there is a right or wrong there, short of, say, beating your kids to a pulp.

There are also multiple ways to diaper babies. Even though I use cloth, that is a preference, not a position of correct-ness. No right or wrong there.

And there are also multiple ways to put kids down to sleep - I love co-sleeping, but I don't think someone is wrong for putting a newborn in a crib instead.

Yes, there are other things I don't agree with, based on the research I've done and the experiences I've had.

There are certain things I think are right and certain things I think are wrong. In parenting. In life, as well.

I assume the same of all us.

I am not shocked that some of you fervently held to your parenting methods yesterday, though they differ from mine. In fact, I applaud you for that, whether you called me names or not.

After all, you are the mother. You know what's best for your babies; I have no say when it comes to what you find right or wrong for your family.

I say that openly, honestly, with my whole heart.

But that also leads me to my last question, which isn't rhetorical, though it may sound that way:

If everyone feels so convicted in their choices, why do you truly care what I think, anyway?
***
I do have a serious side.

I like to talk politics and religion. And I have best friends who are in diametrically opposite faiths and political parties than my own.

We ultimately disagree with each other a lot, but we love each other.

I thought that was normal, but I'm getting the impression lately that far more of you all don't talk about differences with those close to you.

I do feel awkward now, knowing that others aren't coming from the same place as me, knowing that others have not debated faith with their college roommates or politics over the Thanksgiving table.

Maybe that's just my family and my friends. That's OK. I come from passionate stock, I suppose.

And it leaks out into my blog, which yesterday, you all read of your own choice.

But even with that, there was no need to participate in friendly dialogue with me. So those of you who did exchange e-mails with me last night, please know that I truly appreciated it and found a few friends in the mix of this controversy, as well.
***
In closing, I say here's to your beliefs. You have them; I support them. Even if I don't agree with them.

No one ever said I had to, anyway.
***
Happy Thursday, everyone!

17 comments:

Leah said...

The stance you took yesterday didn't bother me at all. I don't think it matters whether I agree with you or not. I also discuss politics and religion A LOT with those close to me. We all don't agree, but we love the discussion.

What bothered me about your post, was that you said, you are right and someone else is wrong.

I would never tell a friend who didn't agree with me on religion, or politics, or parenting they are wrong. Just different. And different IS good. And if someone straight up told me I was wrong because of a choice I was making, I just don't see them being in my life.

Yesterday you blogged about how you are a black and white person, and there IS a right way, and there IS a wrong way, and that we need to take a stance.

And today's post was all about how gray things are in your life. So, I guess I'm a bit confused.

All I know is that my world is very gray. An example I would like to make about my gray world is that I wholeheartedly support our troops and what they do for all of us. And in the same breath, I wholeheartedly disagree with the US occupation in Iraq.

I find there is little in life that doesn't have a gray area. That doesn't mean I don't take a stance. It just means that I recognize nothing is 100% right. . . all of the time.

Jess said...

Ahhhhhh..... I think you hit on a point that I hadn't thought of before.

Yesterday, I blabbered on and on using my "observer's stance." Which really didn't say much, except that I think if you're feeding, clothing, and bathing your kid you've got the most important bases covered, lol.

But, I guess I am not really an observer in the sense that I know you. I've had the pleasure of meeting you and not stealing your kidneys.... and, I had the utmost honor of attending your baby's shower with all of your "real life" loved ones.

So, that's probably why.... even though I'm not a mom yet.... I didn't take the post as an offense or in as harsh a manner as some did.

I *heart* you. That's all, lol.

longbrakeliving said...

I didn't comment yesterday, but I wanted to add a bit of my two cents today.

I had an unmediated birth, but many of my mom friends have had epidurals. I formula-fed, and all but one of my friends breastfed. So I have no problem with those who do things differently from me and being friends with them. That said, I think what struck a bit of a nerve with me yesterday was that the post really seemed to be right vs. wrong.

I think in parenting and families so few things truly are right vs. wrong. Really, the situation seems to be (to me at this point in my parenting experience) about balancing needs and choosing what one child or family member needs most at a particular moment. Does one child need sleep more than another needs social interaction? Does a mother need to establish a schedule so she can care for her child and work (inside or outside the home)? Does a child need to forgo sleep so she can see a parent who works nights and they rarely see?

I think today's post reflects that you realize parenting and family-building are a balancing and compromising act rather than an issue of right and wrong.

I wasn't offended by yesterday's post personally, because I am, like you, convinced that the "big" decisions I've made in caring for my son were what he needed and benefited him and our family the most. I'm not offended that you make different choices for Ella, because we're not the same person, our family situations are different, and we both decisions after careful research and consideration. I was, however, miffed that you came across as all other decisions being wrong because, while you've explained the decisions you've made before, nothing you've written has come across to me in a similar way.

Mrs EyeCanSee said...

As I said yesterday, I'm ok with agreeing to disagree. I was not offended by any means by what you said. Do we agree on things? Nope. But you are confident in the parenting choices you make and I think that's awesome! It's the mom's who apologize for every little choice they do that drives me crazy! It's like they stradle the fence to make everyone happy. At least I know where I stand with you.

I think we'd get along just fine in real life. Especially if you brought me some of the pound cake. :)

Karen said...

First of all - I really enjoy reading your blog, it's very well written and I enjoy your viewpoints. Secondly, I didn't comment on your post yesterday but I did agree with it. You weren't so much saying things are right vs wrong - it's your thoughts on what is right vs your thoughts on what is wrong. And I very much think that everyone is entitled to their own opinions. I agree with a lot of what you said. I think sometimes what I'm doing as a mom is wrong in comparing myself to some of my friends, and some of them think what I'm doing is right. It's all a matter of opinion. Please keep writing - you're fabulous!

Crystal said...

As Leah I'm confused as well. Yesterday's post said you believe people were wrong. You did not say anything about respecting others decisions or about believe it would be wrong for YOU to chose a different path.

As a trained writer, you are able to write a post and insert a tone. I think your an amazing writer and love the picture you paint. But I don't love that you went out of your way to disrespect moms. I can only hope you read all the comments (good and bad) and realized that their are a variety of mom's out there who are trying to do the same thing you are - love their child and create a healthy environment.

Please remember just because we have different beliefs doesn't mean we are "wrong" or bad mothers.

PaigeR530 said...

While you already know that in no way was I offended by your post, even though our opinions differ on a few things, I admire you for this post. I think it is very admirable to be able to say "I'm not sorry for what I said, but for the way I said it." I feel like this is what you are trying to get across today, and I hope those that were offended understand that. You always come from a loving place, and never from a place that berates others. Just know that some of us do recognize that. :)

Katie said...

This was really well written. I really enjoy your blog and I think it is yours to write as you want and it's unfortunate that so many can only retort with namecalling.

Laura said...

First of all let me say, I actually agree with most of your reasoning and decisions you make anyway (eg breastfeeding, cloth diapering, attachment parenting). I also enjoy your blog and hearing your point of view. I think though, that probably what most people had a problem with in your other post was not your choices as a parent, but that you felt compelled to make sure that those who felt differently were wrong in your eyes. I wasn't offended... as I don't often get offended anyway by anything written in blogs. But just trying to see from other people's point of view, I can totally see how many were offended. The whole post was telling people that you felt they were wrong if they did something differently then you, but you could still be their friend anyway. I guess I just didn't see the point.

Hilary Lane said...

Well said. :-) And to that lady who asked if Ella was too old to breastfeed, you should have replied, "Well, I like the child to make that decision. In fact, I have a 5 year old at home who still breast feeds on the regular," just to see the look on her face!

Colleen said...

As you know, I wholeheartedly agree with your stance on breastfeeding. Completely. I mostly agree with your stance on birth. Flintstone is vaccinated because my research indicated to me that that was the best thing to do for him.

We agree and we disagree and none of that really changes my opinion of you. People get so darned riled up about crap these day.

I will say that hearing about babies being left to cry it out really, really hurts me. The idea physically pains me. But I still don't confront people who do it. I have no authority to do so. But I do think it's wrong.

Those are my opinions, and I expect people to respect them as I will respect yours.

The place where people loose my respect is when they fail to think about their decisions.

Newlyweds on a Budget said...

I am not a mom yet, but honestly--what is the BIG DAMN DEAL?!

All you moms go crazy about how to raise babies, and seriously, the kids don't even remember how they were raised! Do you remember being an infant? Because I don't.
I don't know if my mom co-slept with me or not. I know that she breastfeed me before she had to go back to work. But the point is--the chances are extremely small that anything you do will damage your child for life. This goes for breastfeeding moms, formula moms, hippie moms, conservative moms...

gosh, everyone just needs to relax and realize that all moms are doing the best they can for their kids. And look--6 billion people later we're all still alive, whether we were breastfed or not.

btw, i LOVE your blog. and no i am not a mom, so flame me away. but i am just saying, everyone who keeps leaving these nasty comments just needs to take a chill pill. oh yeah, i went there : )

Anonymous said...

Just a question: Do you ever get worried that Ella will be extremely co-dependent on you because you can never put her down or be without her? It just seems like this will make her transition into being independent harder for her.

Sonya said...

This is exactly how I felt you were saying what you said yesterday. The last bit sums it up perfectly.

Oh and imagine me rolling my eyes at anonymous because that comment is absurd!

Lil' Woman said...

This is the post that I think alot more people would have easily related to on the right and wrong subject.

I think my problem was that it was the flat out shutting down and being 'wrong' thing. Different, yes....Wrong, eeeh. We've emailed and we know each others opinion but I don't think I took it so personally because:
1. I don't have a baby yet
2. Others opinions don't really bother considering that's what they are....opinions.

Love your blog, good and bad, and look forward to following for a long time. :)

Crazy Shenanigans-JMO said...

I always say, blog what YOU want to blog about because it is in fact.. YOUR blog!!!

Ashley said...

I'm coming in a little late in the conversation, but I read the post previous to this one before I decided to comment.

First things first, I fall into the category of moms who are completely different from you. My daughter is 2 1/2 and I didn't breastfeed. I didn't do co-sleeping, but I didn't do self soothing either (and to be honest I'm still waiting for her to sleep through the night!). My daughter is up to date on all of the vaccinations my pediatrician told me to give her. These are my parenting choice plain and simple.

With that said, I just want you to know that based on both posts, I never once felt like you were calling me out. What I read was a couple posts by a mom who was sharing her opinion about the "right/wrong" mommy controversy. That's it. I never felt like you were calling me names or forcing your opinion on me. Not once.

I have always appreciated your matter-of-fact style, and I've been reading your blog for over a year now. I like how your not afraid to share your opinion, even to the point of stepping on a few toes. Your honesty is refreshing, and in my opinion, I wish more bloggers that I read were like you.

Thanks for your posts. Thanks for sharing your opinions and thanks for handling the comments from the post before with such grace.

Don't worry, I'll still be reading! ;)